Seller views a Marktplaats furniture listing with a Dutch label saying the advertiser does not respond to messages.

Marktplaats and the Does Not Respond to Messages Label: The Worst Sales Model Ever?

After thirteen years on Marktplaats, I found a label beneath my listings saying that I do not respond to messages. That message immediately puts me at a disadvantage as a seller. I do respond, and my profile shows a 5.0 rating based on four reviews. Yet the platform presents visitors with a negative statement about my responsiveness. On the listing for my TV cabinet, the message appears under Response time.

When I contacted customer service about this, I was told that a response time appears only after ten unique conversations. This creates a peculiar chicken-and-egg problem: potential buyers first see that I supposedly do not respond, while customer service says I need new conversations to get rid of the message. How am I supposed to get those conversations if the platform itself gives people a reason to pass me over? To me, that is one of the worst sales models I can imagine.

Summary

A Marktplaats label saying that a seller does not respond to messages can create a negative impression of someone who says they do respond. According to answers given in my customer service chat, ten unique conversations are needed before a response time appears, but it remained unclear how many conversations counted for my account or which period was used. The message can affect buyers’ willingness to get in touch, making it harder to collect new conversations in the first place. This experience shows how a platform can undermine its own sales process through a poorly chosen status, limited opportunities for verification, and customer service that goes nowhere.

A thirteen-year-old account suddenly becomes a risk

My account has existed for thirteen years. During that time, I have sold various items and also made purchases through Marktplaats. My last visible conversation was dated June 1, 2026, when I bought a laptop from a seller; I had also used the platform in May. When I later listed furniture again, a message appeared beneath my listings saying that I do not respond to messages. My reviews do not prove my current response time, but they are part of my existing relationship with the platform.

What does the label saying a seller does not respond to messages really mean?

I received different explanations in the customer service chat. At first, I was told that the label appears when someone repeatedly fails to respond through Messages. Later, I was told that the text also appears while too few unique conversations count toward a response time, with ten conversations mentioned as the threshold. No one could tell me how many conversations were counted for my account or which period was used.

That distinction is essential. Someone who demonstrably leaves messages unanswered is in a different situation from someone for whom too little recent data is available. When both situations are presented with the same negative sentence, visitors cannot see that uncertainty. The result is a judgment about behavior that, according to the explanation in the chat, may actually be based on insufficient data.

The comparison below shows how different situations could be presented more clearly to a buyer:

SituationClearer information for the visitor
There is too little data.Not enough data for a response time yet.
A response time can be calculated reliably.Show the measured response time with the relevant context.
The accuracy of a status is disputed.Check the data and make it clear that the status is being investigated.

These are proposals for a clearer approach, not a description of Marktplaats’ existing settings. They distinguish between what the platform knows and what it cannot yet establish. The seller is therefore not given a negative label based on missing information. At the same time, the buyer retains access to relevant information once it can actually be displayed reliably.

The chicken-and-egg problem behind ten unique conversations

According to the explanation in my chat, the message disappears once enough unique conversations have taken place. That makes the solution dependent on new interactions. At the same time, the current message can influence the decision to send a first message. That is the wrong order for a platform that aims to bring buyers and sellers together.

A buyer looks at a listing and sees that, according to the platform, the seller does not respond. That buyer may still send a message, but could also choose a similar offer from someone else. Fewer messages then mean fewer opportunities to build up new response times. In this way, the negative indication can perpetuate itself, even when the seller is willing to respond quickly.

If a platform needs new conversations to make trust visible, it should not first discourage those conversations with a negative message.

I cannot demonstrate how many people passed over my listing because of this message. The point is that the platform itself introduces a barrier at a point where trust can make the difference between viewing a listing and making contact. That affects both the seller and the buyer, who may miss out on a suitable product. For the platform, it affects the core of its own value: bringing about successful contacts.

More views cannot make up for lower trust

A screenshot of my TV cabinet listing showed 38 views and zero favorites. Those figures do not prove that visitors dropped out because of the label; price, dimensions, pickup distance, and other factors may also play a role. Without a comparison with listings that do not have the message, its effect cannot be determined reliably. But that uncertainty does not change the question of why a seller with a disputed status should have to try to regain additional trust.

Marktplaats also offers ways to give listings more visibility. For me, it makes no sense to pay for that while the same listing says that I do not respond to messages. Paid reach can bring in more visitors, but it does not remove the negative message from the listing. The risk is that I pay extra to show more people an impression that I dispute.

Being transferred and still getting no answer

To have the message investigated, I contacted customer service several times. In the chat I saved, I was repeatedly told that a colleague would look into it or that I would be transferred. I provided my email address and name so that my account could be identified. At 9:02 p.m., the chat said a colleague was being brought in; at 9:13 p.m., a reply followed under the name Kelly.

After that, I was given the explanation about ten unique conversations again and was told that my account really was being checked. I was not given a specific number of qualifying conversations or the period used. Later in the conversation, I was also told that the exact number could not be retrieved internally. That saved chat alone lasted from 8:41 to 9:59 p.m.: more than an hour and a quarter. My earlier conversations with Marktplaats about the same message were in addition to that.

Customer service that does not have to prove itself

The most telling response came after I asked how many unique conversations were still needed. If my account had actually been checked, I wanted to understand what data supported the message. The response was that the exact number could not be viewed and that the information could not be retrieved internally. The following sentence appeared in the chat:

We do not have to prove ourselves to you any further.

That statement reverses the responsibility. I was not asking to assess an employee’s personal credibility, but for an explanation of a negative statement beneath my listings. The platform determines the visible message and refers to system data in doing so. It is therefore reasonable to ask which data was used, which period applies, and how an error can be corrected.

When customer service says it does not have to prove itself, it is not answering the question about the platform’s own information at that point. The problem is left with the user, even though that user has no access to the underlying calculation. Later, another offer was made to have a colleague look into it. The promise of a check was repeated without making the basis for the status visible.

May an AI agent pose as an employee?

My conversation also raises a broader question: what may an organization suggest when a chatbot says it is bringing in a human colleague? Someone who is first asked for their name and email address and then has to wait may expect an announced transfer to mean something. The transcript states that I spoke with an AI agent and also contains replies under employees’ names. One of those replies contains the following statement at 9:50 p.m.:

I am a real employee and not a bot.

If an AI system says this incorrectly when no human transfer has taken place, that representation may be misleading. A wait and a name then reinforce the impression that the promised employee has joined. The transcript alone does not allow me to establish independently which individual replies were written by a human or by AI. The responsibility for clarifying this lies with the organization providing the customer service.

Since August 2, 2026, Article 50 of the European AI Act has applied to these transparency obligations. Providers of AI systems intended for direct interaction must ensure that people know when they are communicating with AI, unless that is already obvious; the information must be clear and provided no later than the first interaction. The European Commission explains these rules. A notice at the start that a chat uses AI does not, by itself, make clear what happens after a transfer to a colleague has been announced.

Accessibility also deserves attention. The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets explains that intermediary services must offer a contact point through which users can communicate quickly and effectively and that does not rely exclusively on automated means. An alternative contact channel does not automatically mean that every chat question is handled immediately by a human. Whether a platform complies with all applicable rules in a specific situation requires an assessment of how it is actually set up and how accessible it is.

Customer service is part of the sales model

Automation can answer a simple question quickly. Internally, an organization may be pleased with fast first responses or a high number of conversations handled. For a customer who still has no verifiable answer after more than an hour, that says little about the actual solution. A chat closed because the user does not respond quickly enough does not necessarily mean the problem has been resolved either. An organization that focuses only on handling cases can close a problem administratively while it continues to exist commercially.

Marktplaats has new owners and is investing in AI

The organization behind Marktplaats has changed during the time I have used it. eBay bought Marktplaats in 2004; in 2021, Adevinta acquired eBay’s classifieds business, including Marktplaats. In 2024, Adevinta was acquired by an investor group led by Permira and Blackstone and delisted. Marktplaats still describes itself as part of the Adevinta group.

Marktplaats also confirms in its privacy statement that it uses a chatbot for customer service. In a job posting for customer service and AI, the company also describes working with external contact centers and using AI and automation. Those sources show which tools and organizational choices the company mentions. They do not prove that the change of ownership caused my specific label or the way my complaint was handled.

What a platform could measure better

The solution starts with distinguishing between sufficient and insufficient information. When there is too little data, show a neutral message, give the seller insight into the relevant period, and explain when the status will be updated. Make a review possible when someone plausibly shows that the text displayed does not accurately reflect their behavior. This allows the platform to inform buyers without turning missing data into a negative assertion.

In addition, an organization should measure the entire customer journey. For example, compare the proportion of listing visitors who send a message across different statuses, account for price and product category, and investigate how many sellers return after a complaint. Also measure how often a conversation is reopened and whether a complaint has actually been resolved. Those data points show whether an internally efficient process also works commercially.

Finally, a genuine transfer requires ownership. Show clearly when an AI agent is responding and when an employee takes over the conversation. Make sure earlier messages and supplied information remain available, and have someone with the appropriate authority investigate a disputed status. Confirm what has and has not been checked and indicate when the customer can expect a substantive answer.

Trust is the first step toward a sale

A marketplace needs both buyers and sellers who trust that making contact is worthwhile. A negative status on a listing can affect that trust, especially when a user cannot determine where the status comes from. My own experience does not show how many sales I may have lost as a result. It does show how an unclear message and customer service that goes nowhere can together cause an existing user to question the platform.

After thirteen years, I want to sell items, respond to interested buyers, and trust that my profile gives a fair impression of that. According to customer service, I must first have ten unique conversations to do so, while the current message may discourage precisely those conversations. That is the wrong order for a sales platform. A platform that wants more transactions must start with reliable information, accessible support, and a concrete way to have a disputed status corrected.

Related Articles About Trust, Data, and Customer Retention:

↑